| Click image for source |
I often come across beautiful animated renditions of
various viral pathogens, with their symmetrical shape, rounded features, and
overall elegance of design, I almost always forget the power of such small
substances. The Human Papillomavirus (HPV, seen above) is an example of a virus
most of us would probably not suspect to cause such wide spread harm. Unlike
the common flu, or even HIV, HPV often slips under people’s health conscious
radar. Even though it falls under the category of sexually transmitted infection (STI), there are many aspects about its virology, transmission, and
prevention that makes it a unique contribution to the world of STI’s. As I dig
deeper into data surrounding HPV, the more impressed I become at the level of
destruction achieved by something so small and relatively simple.
Falling in the family Papillomaviridae, HPV is a nonenveloped, double-stranded
DNA virus. Isolates of HPV are classified as "types," each designated
on the basis of the nucleotide sequence of specific regions of the genome. All
HPVs have an 8 kilo-base circular genome enclosed in a capsid shell composed of
the major and minor capsid proteins L1 and L2 (depicted in the picture above by
star-shaped structures budding from the surface). Purified L1 protein will
self-assemble to form virus-like particles (VLPs) which are used in vaccines to
trigger antibody production in the recipient.
In addition to the structural genes, the genome
encodes several early genes (E1, E2, E4, E5, E6, and E7) that enable viral
transcription and replication, allowing interaction with the host genome. E6 and
E7 proteins are the primary contributors of cancer; they manipulate cell cycle
regulators, induce chromosomal abnormalities, and block apoptosis. HPV obviously
comes equipped with the tools necessary to complete the job of proper infection;
all it needs is a site of entry into a host so one can witness its
drastic health effects.
HPV enters the body through micro-abrasions that
expose areas of the basement membrane. This disturbed epithelial barrier is
typical during sexual intercourse or after minor skin abrasions. Interestingly,
the use of condoms does not fully protect against infection, as the virus can
be spread through contact by other genital areas not covered. It can also be
spread through oral sex.
Once inside, the infection is limited to the
stratified epithelium, as this is the only tissue within which it can
replicate. Being isolated to this area allows it to be shielded from much of
the body’s immune response. HPV lesions are thought to arise from the
proliferation of infected basal keratinocyte
(the predominate cell type in the epidermis). The circular, double stranded DNA
is transported into the nucleus of these cells and by using host replication machinery;
HPV establishes itself at a copy number between 10-200 viral genomes per cell.
It takes about 12-24 hours for the virus to even initiate transcription,
however; after this period it can proliferate uncontrollably.
Once an HPV viron invades a cell, an active
infection occurs, and the virus can be transmitted. Several months to years may
elapse before it can be clinically detected. I am sure by now the reader is
asking, "Sure the biology behind the virus is interesting, but why
should I care?" To answer this question, we can take a look at the various
detrimental health effects associated with infection.
HPV is a lovely package of afflictions that comes
complete with genital warts and a myriad of cancers that can affect numerous
areas of the body. While genital warts only represent 1% of the active
population, cancers such as, penile, throat, colorectal, and tonsil represent
10,000 cases each year in the U. S. The effect on women is even more severe. HPV
is actually the number one cause of cervical cancer, killing 4000 women each
year. Just knowing these quick facts allows one to realize how dangerous HPV actually
is and it only gets worse when you consider its prevalence in the population.
It is the most common STI in the U.S. According to
the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 45% of college aged woman are
currently infected. There are currently 20 million people infected in the U.S.
with 6 million new infections annually. Most HPV infections are asymptomatic or
simply unrecognized with 90% of people able to clear infection within two
years. Put in another way, about half of sexually active people will contract
HPV some point in their lives.
According to the CDC there are around 120 different
types. Around 30-40 of those are actually associated with sexual transmission. Of
these there are what are considered to be high-risk and low risk types.
High-risk includes cancer causing types and low-risk includes wart causing
types (see below). Interestingly, a viral type cannot cause both; it is either
wart or cancer causing. Given all of this information, it is imperative to have
a means of prevention in order to thwart possible infection.
![]() |
| Click on image for source: Low-risk genital warts |
![]() |
| Click on image for source: High-risk cervical cancer |
Of two vaccines that are currently on the market
today, the most popular is the quadrivalent vaccine, Gardasil, which contains
HPV types 11, 6, 18, and 16. These represent four of the most common types,
with 16 and 18 representing 70% of cervical cancers, 11 and 6 representing 90%
of genital warts. The other vaccine, Cervarix, is a bivalent vaccine containing
types 16 and 18 only. Currently, either vaccine can be administered to women
ages 9-26 with an efficacy close to 100%. As of the October of 2011, the
Gardasil vaccine has also been approved for men between 9-26
years of age. For either gender, administration of the vaccine before the onset
of sexual maturity is optimal. Introducing the vaccine into a young immune
system gives the body the ability to produce sufficient levels of antibodies
against these four main types. This protection of course, comes at a price.
![]() |
| Click on image for source |
Both of the vaccines are administered in a 3 dose
series over a 6 month period with each does costing $120. The total $360 does
not give you fool proof protection. Remember, this vaccine only covers the four
main types and significant time needs to pass before your body produces
sufficient levels of antibodies to fight any sort of exposure. Women who have
received an HPV vaccine should continue routine cervical cancer screening as
30% of cervical cancers are caused by HPV types other than 16 or 18. For anyone
interested in getting the vaccine, it is important to know that it does not
eliminate the need to have regular cervical screens and will not help cure a
current infection.
More recently, the use of the HPV vaccine has been
under political debate. Following its introduction in 2006, Gardasil
has been proposed as a possible mandatory vaccine. In 2007 Texas Governor Rick Perry aimed to pass an executive order that would mandate the vaccination for all young girls in Texas. The bill was met with much opposition
and, even though it did not pass, the idea of an HPV vaccine mandate still
lingers.
The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices(ACIP) put forth their recommendation for the use of an HPV vaccine by taking
into account much of the information discussed in this article. ACIP models have
suggested that vaccination of an entire cohort of females aged 12 years could
reduce the lifetime risk for cervical cancer by 20%-66%, depending on the
efficacy of the vaccine and the duration of vaccine protection. One study
assumed 100% vaccine coverage, 90% vaccine efficacy against HPV 16/18, and lifetime
duration of protection. Under these assumptions, an estimated 58% reduction was
achieved in the lifetime risk for cervical cancer for the vaccinated cohort.
In
a summary of their findings, ACIP suggests routine vaccination of females aged 11-12
years based on several considerations, including studies suggesting that
quadrivalent HPV vaccine among adolescents will be safe and effective, high
antibody counts achieved after vaccination at age 11-12 years, and the high
probability of HPV acquisition within several years of sexual debut.
Regardless
of the vaccine debate, there is no argument that HPV presents a mounting threat
to the sexually active population in the United States. The virus, so
beautifully depicted by animated images and models, remains sinister in its
behavior. Stealthy existence in the host, ease of transmission, and fine-tuned
virology make it an expert pathogen. Reading articles like this and doing basic
research on the internet is a useful way for people to protect themselves, providing a basis from which to cultivate an appreciation and fear of the possible detrimental health effects
associated with infection. Getting vaccinated is a proactive way to shield oneself from the growing HPV problem that is sweeping the nation. Hopefully, as
HPV’s reputation as a killer spreads and more people begin to protect themselves,
it will prevent many needless deaths.



The two blogs concerning HPV complement each other well. While Kevin McNaught's blog provides a big picture view of how the HPV issue fits into the history and framework of vaccinations, Srdjan Kamenko's blog provides a detailed blow-by-blow description of the the virus, how it is transmitted and what it does. The prevalence of the HPV viruses are truly surprising and their ability to be "silent" or remain undetected for so long make them particularly scary.
ReplyDeleteThe one figure that I have not seen cited that seems particularly important is the relative proportion of the different virus types within the infected population. In the Javitt et al. (2008) article, the authors state "Many women will never be exposed to the cancer-causing strains of HPV; indeed the prevalence of these strains in the U.S. is quite low." If this is the case, while the percent of the population infected by HPVs may be quite high, if the percent of cancer-causing HPVs within this infected population is low, then the high infection rate, in general, may not be that meaningful. It is hard to assess the true threat and how "scary" these viruses are without these critical figures.